Some pretty good news from the Democratic Convention, and a new threat to the voting system
by Rob Tiller
The big event for us this week was the Democratic Convention. I can’t say I was looking forward to it. I seriously doubted that a virtual convention could be anything other than boring, and there was a possibility it would be a debacle. But it was much more gratifying than I expected, and left me more hopeful.
There were some moments that seemed stagey and artificial, but there were also moments of surprising authenticity and feeling. Ordinary people spoke in their own words about their concerns. While there was a celebration of our diversity (of races, origins, orientations), there was also recognition that we face enormous challenges (achieving racial justice, economic fairness, climate stabilization). Part of the main message was that we’re dealing with a lot of pain (pandemic deaths, loss of jobs, uncertainty) that needs to be acknowledged and respected, and then addressed.
The thrust of the Convention was straightforward: we have a disastrous President, and now we have a chance to replace him and do better. Criticism of Trump was almost all about his utter failure to do his job, rather than his moral failings — his disastrous mismanagement of the pandemic, of health care, of the economy, the environment, of international relations, and the rest, while cutting taxes for fat cats.
This was probably a reasonable approach for persuading those who previously voted for Trump but might consider changing. It just makes no sense to renew the contract of a bad CEO.
As for change, there’s Joe Biden. Frankly, I’ve never been a huge Biden fan. He seemed to me an establishment guy unlikely to be a strong force for progress. But I felt a lot more supportive after seeing more of him and learning more about his story.
The basic case for Biden, as I heard it, is: he’s a really decent, hardworking, and compassionate guy, with solid experience, knowledge, and values. He’s not bucking to get his face on Mount Rushmore. But he wants to help right the ship of state, for the right reasons, and he’s got the necessary skills. It seemed like he’s evolved in some positive ways, like many of us, with more concern for addressing racial injustice, gender inequities, and climate change challenges.
Biden is, of course, a politician. I had assumed that his big handsome smile was mostly a politician’s trick and to be regarded with some suspicion. But there was substantial testimony to the effect that he’s an unusually warm, caring, compassionate person. His choice of Kamala Harris suggests political savvy, but also that he’s got a big heart.
Some of our issues that urgently need attention didn’t get much at the Convention. I heard almost nothing about nuclear arms control and reducing the risk of nuclear or other conflicts. There was only a brief mention of the environmental costs of factory farming, and none that I heard about its appalling brutality and the welfare of animals. There seemed to be little recognition that technology, including artificial intelligence, is changing our economic reality, and our old model for education and jobs isn’t going to work as well in the future.
So I’m not expecting that Joe and the Democrats will quickly fix all our societal problems. But I am hopeful that they’ll make a start. As the old saying goes, the first thing to do when you’re in a hole is to stop digging. I’m pretty sure they’ll stop digging, and also that they’ll try to help those who need it right now. That would be a huge change.
The Convention sent a strong message about the importance of voting in this election. In a nutshell, if you care at all about preserving the good things about our system, you need to vote. Barring a quick miracle cure to the pandemic, it’s probably best to do so by getting a mail in ballot and getting it in early. As noted in my last post, in some states you can drop off your mail-in ballot directly with local officials.
Voting used to seem simple — a little boring, but something we could all agree was basically a good thing. Even after years of Republican efforts to reduce or prevent voting by their opposition, it’s still hard to believe what has been happening recently.
Trump, McConnell, and other Republican leaders have admitted that it would be, for them, a disaster if everyone voted, because they could not possibly win. They feel well justified in putting up roadblocks to voting by people of color, young people, and others, such as new voter ID laws, fewer polling places, more limited voting hours, and now, attacks on the Postal Service. Their power is at stake. For them, democracy is a problem.
We have a long history of voter intimidation in the US, and Trump announced last week plans to revive the practice. He referred to getting local sheriffs to the polls, ostensibly to prevent fraud, which, of course, they have no way to do. They can, however, display their weapons and stare grimly at unwelcome voters, such as people of color.
Even the worry that this might happen could well discourage some people from trying to vote. Especially when combined with other problems, like missing voter registrations and long lines, there will be some attrition. The more chaotic the voting process is, the better for Trump.
Part of the Trumpist idea seems to be to destroy confidence in our system. Thus we have Trump’s constant and baseless allegations of widespread voter fraud. Among the bizarre things Trump said last week was this: the only way he could lose was if the election was rigged.
With polls showing him trailing, this seems delusional, but also disturbing. He seems to be saying: I will not accept any election result except one where I win. In other words, American democracy is over.
But Trump says a lot of things that aren’t true, and promises a lot of things he doesn’t deliver. So I’m not giving up on the idea that he can be removed from office in the ordinary manner — by the people voting. But we can’t kid around on this one. This time, voting really matters.